Welcome!

Welcome to Satlover forums, full of great people, ideas and excitement.

Please register if you would like to take part. link..

Register Now

Alert: Don't Use Hotmail Email Accounts for registration

Collapse

Before Access to all Forums and Trial accounts you must need to activate your account Email address

how to detect fake hop1?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mmoloch
    Member
    • Mar 2013
    • 75

    how to detect fake hop1?

    I have two Golden Media Spark reloaded running in Spark side with oscam4tools or oscamymod t39 plugins for my 5 clines.

    In the oscam4tools webif I see that all the cards are in hop1, if I ping the cs server with windows promt I have get 60ms but some channels give 600ms, 3000ms...

    Status log

    2013/06/06 16:31:05 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/78:2584/B8-14): found (691 ms) by 3 (5 of 5)

    2013/06/06 16:31:16 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/78:A72D/B8-AE): found (667 ms) by 4 (5 of 5)
    2013/06/06 16:31:40 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/78:0784/F3-AE): found (239 ms) by 4 (5 of 5)

    2013/06/06 16:32:05 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/787CA/F3-CD): found (386 ms) by 1 (5 of 5)
    2013/06/06 16:32:30 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/78:589F/F6-CD): found (409 ms) by 5 (5 of 5)
    2013/06/06 16:32:56 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0500&042400/20F6/14DE/0000/78:68DE/F6-2F): found (915 ms) by 4 (1 of 5)

    2013/06/06 16:25:20 1838 2D7FF4C8 c dvbapi (0604&000000/0161/05FE/000E/4C:C1E2/E2-7A): found (3783 ms) by 2 (2 of 5) (try 2)


    This means that the server has fake hop1?

    Another problem... JSC Sport channels that open quickly in oscam4tools take more than 10 seconds to open with oscamymod and Nova channels do not open at all with oscamymod... why?!... the files are the same, same oscam.server, same oscam.conf, etc etc.

    In oscam status I can't identify any problem, is there any way to get a oscam log to identify the problem?

    In oscam status what is the meaning of LB Value / Reader? I have 2210, 3674, no data, 550 and 3364.

    My oscam.server was generated automatically by Streamboard OSCAM 1.10rc-svn build... my reader:

    [reader]
    label = 1
    protocol = cccam
    device = ----------------
    key = 0102030405060708091011121314
    user = --------------
    password = ---------
    reconnecttimeout = 8010600
    group = 1
    cccversion = 2.1.4
    cccmaxhops = 2
    cccwantemu = 1
    ccckeepalive = 1


    Is right?... if I change reconnecttimeout to 5 LB Value / Reader change to no data... in oscam status shows cccam (2.0.11-2892) protocol, should I chang cccversion to 2.0.11 or keep 2.1.4?
  • gianni253
    Experienced Board Member
    • Nov 2012
    • 903

    #2
    Re: how to detect fake hop1?

    Your ecm times are showing that 90% it's not a hop1 server.
    Ping time is useless because ping udp packets go straight to your server but ecm requests have to travel across more servers behind your server.
    Sorry but I don't know much about oscam4tools or oscamymod but my guess is about the different way they manage card priorities ... trying first to decode with internal emu, and then with cs server (and here is the origin of delays).
    Why not a pure oscam ?

    Comment

    • mmoloch
      Member
      • Mar 2013
      • 75

      #3
      Re: how to detect fake hop1?

      The receiver has a sh4 cpu, only supports oscam.sh4 versions, many versions only work on enigma2 and I have to use Spark because enigma2 gives black and white image (problem of tv), have tested several versions but all have some problem.

      I've read that the receiver supports some old versions of pure oscam but still have not tested any, there is any good old version?

      Comment

      • gianni253
        Experienced Board Member
        • Nov 2012
        • 903

        #4
        Re: how to detect fake hop1?

        Originally posted by mmoloch
        ... there is any good old version?
        svn3144 aka v1.00 is dated 2010-09-21 and is considered a milestone in old oscam versions.
        I would give a try ...

        Comment

        • Satphoenix
          Experienced Board Member
          • Oct 2012
          • 999

          #5
          Re: how to detect fake hop1?

          Often you only have the chance to check it indirectly.

          Too long answer times for ecm requests (which mean glitches or freezes) are a possibility.
          Many free servers are often hop1 fakes.
          Or the "problem child" nds gives a good indicator for that.
          If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans!

          Comment

          • herrr
            Experienced Board Member
            • Jan 2012
            • 1081

            #6
            Re: how to detect fake hop1?

            Originally posted by Satphoenix
            Often you only have the chance to check it indirectly.

            Too long answer times for ecm requests (which mean glitches or freezes) are a possibility.
            Many free servers are often hop1 fakes.
            Or the "problem child" nds gives a good indicator for that.
            As a matter of facts I don't agree that ping doesn't matter, as someone said before: it's very useful to compare ECM and ping times.

            Comment

            • gianni253
              Experienced Board Member
              • Nov 2012
              • 903

              #7
              Re: how to detect fake hop1?

              Originally posted by herrr
              As a matter of facts I don't agree that ping doesn't matter, as someone said before: it's very useful to compare ECM and ping times.
              Ping matters as long as it's time is too long: in this case you will have bad results anyway.
              But if it is very fast it doesn't mean you will have fast ecms, because you don't know how many hops is your "real" cs server far.

              Comment

              • herrr
                Experienced Board Member
                • Jan 2012
                • 1081

                #8
                Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                Originally posted by gianni253
                Ping matters as long as it's time is too long: in this case you will have bad results anyway.
                But if it is very fast it doesn't mean you will have fast ecms, because you don't know how many hops is your "real" cs server far.
                All what you say is obvious...
                But we were not talking about what's matter to see good TV... but how to find out if there is a fake, and ping matters for accounting.
                I meant that the only way to be sure if hop1 is a fake is to evaluate net time (without the amount you can measure with ping).
                If this is unbelievable as ECM response time, so there is a fake.

                Comment

                • runmo
                  Experienced Board Member
                  • Jun 2010
                  • 6123

                  #9
                  Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                  keep it to the subject please, thank you

                  Comment

                  • mirny
                    Experienced Board Member
                    • Nov 2011
                    • 707

                    #10
                    Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                    Originally posted by mmoloch
                    [reader]
                    label = 1
                    protocol = cccam
                    device = ----------------
                    key = 0102030405060708091011121314
                    user = --------------
                    password = ---------
                    reconnecttimeout = 8010600
                    group = 1
                    cccversion = 2.1.4
                    cccmaxhops = 2
                    cccwantemu = 1
                    ccckeepalive = 1

                    just a litlle corection cccam protociol dont use a key, deskey is for newcamnd protocol,so you can delete that line
                    HD-BOX FS-9200,SkyStar HD2 USB CI, Skystar2 90Fe Motor, 85Al Multifeed

                    If you like my post, or was helpful, don't be shy and press the Thanks Button.

                    Comment

                    • Satphoenix
                      Experienced Board Member
                      • Oct 2012
                      • 999

                      #11
                      Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                      Mostly there are many cards connected to a server. If a few of them answer very fast, they are mostly on hop1, if others of them answer very slow, although the are declared as hop1 the chance is big, that hop1 a fake on this cards.
                      Thats what I meant with indirect.
                      If you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans!

                      Comment

                      • SatWaveDude
                        Board Senior Member
                        • Apr 2012
                        • 220

                        #12
                        Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                        I dont understand how a fake can be show as a hop1, it normaly shows up as a hop2 or do I get this wrong?
                        SatWaveDude

                        DM500HD, DM500+ | EMP S16/1PCP-W3 | WaveFrontier T90 | 16x SMART Titanium 0.1dB LNB's
                        TechniSat SkyStar S2 PCI / SkyStar USB HD
                        WaveFrontier T90 rev.2 - 28.2E | 23.5E | 19.2E | 16E | 13E | 10/9E | 3.3E | 4/5E | 0.8W | 7/8W | 12.5W

                        If you find my post usefull please press the Thanks Button

                        Comment

                        • gianni253
                          Experienced Board Member
                          • Nov 2012
                          • 903

                          #13
                          Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                          Originally posted by SatWaveDude
                          I dont understand how a fake can be show as a hop1, it normaly shows up as a hop2 or do I get this wrong?
                          [sensitive info deleted]

                          This is something really unfair that should never be done.
                          So, as mmoloch pointed out, you can't trust the hop information and have to investigate further with ping and ecm times to understand if it is a fake hop1

                          Comment

                          • SatWaveDude
                            Board Senior Member
                            • Apr 2012
                            • 220

                            #14
                            Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                            is there no such protection against this?
                            so we have to whatch the ecm rates to find out if or not it is fake!
                            SatWaveDude

                            DM500HD, DM500+ | EMP S16/1PCP-W3 | WaveFrontier T90 | 16x SMART Titanium 0.1dB LNB's
                            TechniSat SkyStar S2 PCI / SkyStar USB HD
                            WaveFrontier T90 rev.2 - 28.2E | 23.5E | 19.2E | 16E | 13E | 10/9E | 3.3E | 4/5E | 0.8W | 7/8W | 12.5W

                            If you find my post usefull please press the Thanks Button

                            Comment

                            • gianni253
                              Experienced Board Member
                              • Nov 2012
                              • 903

                              #15
                              Re: how to detect fake hop1?

                              Originally posted by SatWaveDude
                              is there no such protection against this?
                              so we have to whatch the ecm rates to find out if or not it is fake!
                              AFAIK no protection.
                              Ecm time analysis, combined with ping responses, is the only way to know.
                              That's why you should trust only well established and good reputation servers (such as Satlover ! )

                              Comment

                              Working...